Talk:Pirate Medicine

This article is way too complex. It's too difficult to navigate the information in the way it's presented, nor can we expect to have this information verified any time soon; all of the articles that we do this sort of thing with would have to include DB verification tags, and these tags would likely never be removed. It sets the bar for newcomers extremely high as well, and there's too many spoilers. I think the only dialogue choices we should document are those that alter the course of a mission and those that provide alignment points. I also believe we should limited quoted dialog to information that could be used to provide lore information elsewhere in the project. This include after-mission correspondence, which usually contains no new information and serves as nothing more than a plot spoiler. -- Heaven&#39;s Agent 18:41, 9 January 2012 (UTC)


 * I disagree. Isn't the wiki's goal "to become the most complete and wide-ranging information source for Star Wars: The Old Republic on the internet"? This article documents the relevant information of the mission, including affection changes which are important to some. The formatting can be tweaked if needed and even make the dialog section expandable if you want, but I feel the dialog and correspondence belong in the article. As far as verification, from what I've seen of the Jedi Knight dialog options, they are correct. Having information in there, even if it's incorrect, is better than no information. That way, people can edit what's wrong rather than try to figure out if something belongs and where.


 * I would like to see input from the community on this so I'm copying this discussion to the forum. -- 19:21, 9 January 2012 (UTC)